What I had in my head and what I finished are not the same. I ended up choosing a simple matte finish polish called Get It On by Sinful Colors from the Leather Luxe collection. These polishes are awesome. I picked up 4 of them and want to get the rest. The formula on this one was bit tricky because it did not want to level out. I then just did a simple stamp with China Glaze Ruby Pumps using Mash plate 48 for the flames. It looked way different under different lighting and I found that to be a fun and unexpected "feature" of this manicure. I preferred it with the darker shade of red and more of the obvious flame showing but it's still pretty both ways. I was warned this polish stains but it didn't really stain for me which was a plus. I wasn't over the moon with this design but I didn't hate it either. I spent way too much time figuring out what to do.
I would like to revisit the idea of red nail art in the near future. I didn't give it as much love as I should have.